Why You Need Our Peanut Butter Whiskey

Don’t knock it until you’ve tried it; Peanut Butter Whiskey is the hottest thing on the menu this season. If you’re not used to seeing peanut butter anywhere other than side-by-side with a smear of jelly, don’t worry. We have the ultimate peanut butter whiskey guide to help you navigate this exciting new flavor. Trust us; it’s a game-changer!

How to Drink Peanut Butter Whiskey

Peanut butter whiskey is a true indulgence. Think rich swirls of caramel-peanut tones offset by smooth 80 Proof Tennessee whiskey traditionally distilled and aged. 

Do you drink peanut butter whiskey straight? Yes, peanut butter whiskey is delicious on its own over on the rocks. However, if you want to test this new spirit out and see how it can really perform, pairing it with other flavors is the way to go. Whether you prefer a creamy cocktail, a hot milky beverage, or you want to satisfy your sweet tooth with a cheeky dessert, peanut butter whiskey is an all-round crowd pleaser. These are our top five suggestions for this year’s edgiest whiskey. 

1. Enjoy it with your coffee

Sure, we know Irish coffees are the big name on the boozy caffeinated drinks scene, but we feel peanut butter whiskey swirled into a hot coffee deserves some stage time, too. The warm, rounded flavors work perfectly with coffee (both hot and iced coffee, in our opinion!), adding an additional nuttiness that pairs perfectly with milk or milk alternatives. 

2. Pair it with a hot brownie

This incredibly simple dessert gives impressive results. Warm a chocolate brownie, top it with a slosh of peanut butter whiskey, and finish with a scoop of ice cream. It’s like a Reese’s cup with attitude. 

3. Put a spin on an old classic

Whiskey and cola: the proof that sometimes less is more. This recipe requires zero effort and is perfect for those warm nights when you want a drink that’s simple yet packed with flavor. 

Swap your usual spirit for peanut butter whiskey for a refreshing take on this classic.

4. Recreate your favorite sandwich

In drinks form, of course. Turn a PB&J into the perfect cocktail by muddling your favorite berries until they release juices. Add them to a glass along with a shot of peanut butter whiskey and some simple syrup, and top with club soda. 

If you don’t want to use fresh fruit, try the same recipe using actual jelly. Alternatively, swap out the simple syrup for berry-flavored syrup for similar results. 

Buy Peanut Butter Whiskey at Old Tennessee Distilling Company

Meet the trends as they happen by stocking up on our award-winning spirits. At our distillery in Kodak, TN, you’ll find peanut butter whiskey and the rest of our flavored whiskey range, including other enticing flavors like chocolate caramel and dark chocolate almond wafer. While visiting, you can also stock up on moonshine, vodka, rum, liqueurs, brandy, and our traditional award-winning whiskies.

We’re open seven days a week; join us for free tastings, $5 cocktails, and more.